Head-to-head, mom to mom
Alloy vs Midi Health
Alloy and Midi Health both offer GLP-1 telehealth, but they make different trade-offs on signup ease, honest pricing, which meds you can get, state coverage and support. Here they are side-by-side on the Mom-Tested Score — our real-mom rubric.
Alloy vs Midi Health at a glance
Short answer: Alloy comes out ahead on visit format and signup ease, while Midi Health comes out ahead on state coverage and insurance billing. The sections below give the exact figures.
| Detail | Alloy | Midi Health |
|---|---|---|
| Semaglutide, standing rate | Tied to a plan term or membership; not month to month | Billing period not defined |
| Tirzepatide, standing rate | Tied to a plan term or membership; not month to month | Billing period not defined |
| Yearly difference | Not comparable: no pair of confirmed standing rates in the same billing period | |
| States served | Limited service area | All 50 states |
| Brand-name GLP-1s | Yes | Yes |
| Oral or sublingual | Yes | Yes |
| Visit format | No video | Video |
| FDA warning letter | None on record | None on record |
| Mom-Tested Score | 85/100 | 79/100 |
Full wording for states served and visit format
States served
- Alloy
- 48 states + DC (not LA or MS); compounded also unavailable in AL, AR, CA, NV and DC
- Midi Health
- All 50 states
Visit format
- Alloy
- No video visit required
- Midi Health
- Video visit required
Alloy
Higher scoreRanked #3 for moms · Grade B
- walked the public signup
- tracked the real cost
- read the fine print
Best for: Moms in perimenopause or menopause who want a doctor who understands the hormone side, who'd rather choose between six medications than one, and who will do the $99-plus-medication maths before they sign up.
Visit AlloyMidi Health
Ranked #23 for moms · Grade B−
- walked the public signup
- tracked the real cost
- read the fine print
Best for: Women in midlife who want a real clinician relationship — often billable to a PPO plan — and who can genuinely get to a scheduled video visit, with the medication priced openly before they commit.
Visit Midi HealthThe verdict
Alloy edges out Midi Health on the Mom-Tested Score, 85 to 79 (B vs B−). Moms in perimenopause or menopause who want a doctor who understands the hormone side, who'd rather choose between six medications than one, and who will do the $99-plus-medication maths before they sign up.
Midi Health is still a genuine option — midi publishes a dose-based four-week GLP-1 medication grid with visits priced separately at $250 initially and $150 thereafter for self-pay. Generic category labels and conflicting oral-tirzepatide starting prices mean the exact medication and bill need confirmation. Weigh the six mom factors below against your own priorities.
Alloy and Midi Health don't publish semaglutide prices in the same billing period, so their headline figures can't be set side by side. That makes intro prices versus what you pay later the better yardstick than any single number. Ask both for the full recurring charge and the supply it covers.
Both offer brand-name medication, which makes Zepbound and Wegovy self-pay prices the right figures to hold each quote against. Midi Health says it bills health insurance for its own care and Alloy doesn't say that, which is a separate question from whether the medication is covered, the subject of getting a GLP-1 covered by insurance. CoreAge Rx, our featured partner, is another name worth pricing against either provider's quote. However those differences land for you, a prescriber still decides whether treatment is appropriate.
Where this pair lands against the rest of the roster depends on what you're optimizing, and the best GLP-1 for women board covers providers that publish a real monthly price, scored for moms rather than for the average shopper. The Mom-Tested Score gap here, 85 to 79, is an editorial judgment rather than a lab result, so weigh it against your own priorities.
Side-by-side on the six factors
Both providers scored on the same real-mom rubric — the higher side on each factor is marked. See the methodology.
Price: the gap per billing period and per year
Neither Alloy nor Midi Health has a confirmed month-to-month price on record for either molecule, so there is no price gap to calculate. Ask each for the complete recurring charge, the supply it covers and any required membership before comparing quotes.
States: where each one serves
Alloy describes a limited service area that I cannot read as an exact list, and Midi Health says it serves all 50 states. Because at least one side is not an exact list, I cannot name the states one covers and the other does not. Check your own state on each site before you pay.
Medications: brand, compounded, oral and molecules
Alloy lists semaglutide and tirzepatide with brand-name options and an oral or sublingual form. Midi Health lists semaglutide and tirzepatide with brand-name options and an oral or sublingual form.
Visit format, what the price includes and signup
Visit format: Alloy is recorded as "No video visit required" and Midi Health as "Video visit required".
Alloy's price includes the clinician consult, which Midi Health's does not; Midi Health's price includes the medication, which Alloy's does not.
From the signups I walked: Alloy publishes a phone line, email, posted hours for support and Midi Health publishes email.
Midi Health says it bills health insurance for its own care; Alloy does not say that. That is separate from whether your plan covers the medication itself.
FDA warning letters and where the scores differ most
Neither Alloy nor Midi Health has an FDA warning letter of its own on record in our review.
On signup ease (Nap-time-easy signup), Alloy scores 86 and Midi Health scores 58, a 28-point gap in favor of Alloy.
On state coverage (Works in your state), Alloy scores 74 and Midi Health scores 88, a 14-point gap in favor of Midi Health.
On cancellation, both score close together (Alloy 76, Midi Health 81); each review has the exact terms.
Which one fits you
Pick Alloy if
- You want to start without a live video visit; Midi Health asks for one.
- You weigh signup ease most: it scores 86 against 58 on our rubric.
Pick Midi Health if
- You want coverage stated more plainly: Alloy's service area is not an exact list I can read.
- You would rather a clinician review you in a live video visit, which Midi Health requires.
- You want a provider that says it bills health insurance for its own care.
These lines come only from the differences above. If a line is missing for one side, the recorded data gives it no edge on that point, and prices and terms change, so confirm on each provider's own site.
Alloy
Ranked #3 · Grade B
What we like
- The widest formulary on this site: brand Zepbound and its KwikPen, brand Wegovy pen and pill, the oral Foundayo, and compounded semaglutide, tirzepatide and liraglutide
- No video visit — an async intake, with a plan promised in under 12 hours
- Unlimited messaging with the same menopause-trained physician, included in the fee rather than billed per visit
The caveats
- A mandatory $99/mo fee sits on top of every advertised price, so the real floor is $169, not the $70 on the page
- Every price is a "starting at" figure with no dose table — Wegovy is shown as $199 against a struck-through $499 with nothing explaining the gap
- For brand medication you're billed by two companies: Alloy for the fee, NovoCare or LillyDirect for the drug
Midi Health
Ranked #23 · Grade B−
What we like
- A full dose-by-dose price list published openly, shipping and supplies included, with "No membership fees" stated on the page
- In-network with most PPO plans, so the visit can run through insurance rather than out of pocket
- Publishes injectable and sublingual GLP-1 categories, plus brand prescribing through your chosen pharmacy
The caveats
- A scheduled 30-minute video visit is the only way in, with the questionnaire due 24 hours early and a text confirmation required to keep the slot
- The generic GLP-1 injection price rises from $165.90 to $355 per four-week supply as its published dose tier rises
- Visit fees are billed on top of the medication: $250 for the first and $150 for each one after, if you're self-pay
Alloy vs Midi Health: quick answers
Which is cheaper, Alloy or Midi Health?
Neither Alloy nor Midi Health has a confirmed month-to-month price on record for either molecule, so there is no price gap to calculate. Ask each for the complete recurring charge, the supply it covers and any required membership before comparing quotes.
Does Alloy or Midi Health serve more states?
Alloy describes a limited service area that I cannot read as an exact list, and Midi Health says it serves all 50 states. Because at least one side is not an exact list, I cannot name the states one covers and the other does not. Check your own state on each site before you pay.
Do Alloy and Midi Health require a video visit?
Visit format: Alloy is recorded as "No video visit required" and Midi Health as "Video visit required". Their visit formats differ, so check which one fits your week before you pay.
Has Alloy or Midi Health received an FDA warning letter?
Neither Alloy nor Midi Health has an FDA warning letter of its own on record in our review.
Some providers we list are partners, and we may be paid when you sign up through our links, at no cost to you. That can affect which providers we feature. Pricing, states and verification reflect each provider's public disclosures at last review; the Mom-Tested Score is our editorial judgment per the methodology. Prices change — confirm on each provider's site. Not medical advice; see our disclosure.
More head-to-heads
Keep comparing Alloy and Midi Health against other providers I reviewed for moms.
- Midi Health vs Trimi Health
- Knownwell vs Midi Health
- Midi Health vs Sesame Care
- CoreAge Rx vs Midi Health
- Midi Health vs Noom Med
- Midi Health vs TeleZen MD
Or browse the full comparison hub.